Menus
Mini Plate
-
Broiled Oysters (4)
roasted apple-fennel compound butter, grilled bread
$21
Maxie Plate
-
Cajun-Seared Rainbow Trout
tomato-crab cream sauce, white cheddar-herb grits, roasted broccoli & carrots
$39
Sweet Plate
-
Chocolate Chess Pie
spiced chocolate graham cracker crust, Frangelico caramel sauce, chocolate sauce, freshly whipped cream
$13
MAXIE'S STANDS WITH ALL WHO OBJECT TO RACISM, VIOLENCE, AND BIGOTRY
Click here to reserve a table
Soup & Salads
-
Maxie’s Mighty-Mighty Gumbo
with andouille sausage & chicken, over rice
cup $9
bowl $12
jumbo $16
-
Crab and Corn Chowder
cup $10
bowl $13
-
Supper Club Salad
local field greens, bleu cheese, toasted pecans & fresh apple, raspberry vinaigrette
small $12
full $16
-
Caesar Salad
romaine lettuce with traditional caesar dressing, parmesan cheese and garlic croutons
small $11
full $15
-
Add to Your Salad
chicken breast 8 / catfish 12/ shrimp 10 / ahi tuna 12/ fried oysters 13/ portobello 7/ BBQ organic tofu 7
Appetizers
-
NOLA BBQ SHRIMP
spicy worcestershire-rosemary sauce, garlic bread
$14
-
Fried Green Tomatoes
with remoulade
$12
-
Broiled Oysters (4pc)
chef's daily preparation
mkt
-
Cracker-Crusted Oysters
with creamy mignonette
$19
-
Gumbo Fries
loaded with cheddar cheese, gumbo gravy
$15
-
Crab Cake
with cajun mayo & rwb slaw
$20
-
Peel n Eat Shrimp
chilled, dusted with old bay seasoning
1/4# $11
1/2# $17
-
Steamed Littleneck Clams
in garlic butter broth with grilled french bread
(12) $26
(18) $36
Sandwiches
w/ lettuce, tomato & Maxie pickles. add any side for $5-
Bleu Cheese Burger
with caramelized onions and mayo
$17
-
Fried Shrimp
with remoulade
$18
-
Chicken
grilled, bbq, fried or blackened, with mayo
$17
-
Fried Oysters
with creamy mignonette
$20
-
Blackened Catfish
with tartar sauce
$19
-
BBQ Organic Tofu
topped with creamy slaw
$16
-
Andouille Sausage
with remoulade, 'rwb' slaw
$18
Kid's Menu
-
Chicken Fingers
with french fries
$11.95
-
Pulled Pork Sandwich
with fries
$11.50
-
Kid's Fried Shrimp
with french fries
$11.95
-
Kid's Fish Fry
with fries
$11.95
-
BBQ Organic Tofu
with french fries
$10.95
-
Grilled Cheese
with fries
$10.95
-
Kid's Noodles
with butter and cheese
$9.50
We will gladly substitute mashed potatoes, creamy cole slaw or fresh apple slices for fries at no charge for items on the kid's menu.
Maxie’s Soul-Stirrin’ Classics
-
Shrimp and Grits
shrimp, rich tasso ham gravy, over grits
half $21
full $28
add andouille sausage $6
-
Jambalaya “Me-Oh-My-A”
shrimp, local andouille, & chicken in zesty creole rice
$26
-
Vegan Jambalaya
smoked tofu, pecans, spinach, & black beans in creole rice
$23
-
Maxie's Deluxe Crab Cake Platter
with cajun mayo and rwb slaw
$38
-
Cajun-Seared Ahi Tuna
maple brown butter, horseradish potato cake, sautéed spinach
$38
-
Chicken-Fried Chicken
with mashed potatoes, tasso gravy and maple-braised collard greens
$24
-
Blackened Catfish
creole sauce, black beans and rice, maple-braised collard greens
$25
-
Pulled Pork Sandwich
Eastern NC style, topped with slaw, on a sesame roll, BBQ beans
$21
-
Pulled Pork Plate
Eastern NC style, BBQ beans, Traditional Slaw
$23
Add Adnouille Sausage $6
-
Fish Fry-or-Shrimp Fry
with tartar or cocktail sauce, rough-cut fries, creamy slaw
$25
-
Blackened Fish Tacos
soft corn tortillas, pico de gallo, lettuce, side of black beans and rice
$24
-
Grilled Portobello
with creole sauce, horseradish potato cake, baby spinach
$23
-
BBQ Organic Tofu
KC-style, mashed potatoes, sautéed spinach
$21
Sides-n-Fries
-
Grits and Gravy
$8.50
-
Maple-Braised Collard Greens
$8
-
BBQ Beans
$6.50
-
Slaw: ‘RWB’ -Or- Creamy
$6.50
-
Vegan Black Beans & Rice
$6.50
-
Sautéed Spinach
$7.50
-
Mashed Potatoes
$7.50
-
Spicy Cajun Fries
with cajun mayo
side $7
basket $10
-
Rough-Cut Fries
side $6.50
basket $9
-
Field Greens
Choice of dressing
$8
-
The freshest sustainably raised and wild caught oysters, fish and seafood from North America's east coast are ice-packed and trucked directly to Maxie's. Maxie's locally sources many natural products including Ithaca Soy organic tofu, Red Gate Grocers andouille sausage, locally-grown and milled grits, and seasonal produce from local farms practicing organic and biodynamic methods.
Raw Bar
raw oysters, raw clams and peel n' eat shrimp available. check the chalkboards for pricing and variety OYSTER HAPPY HOUR 3:30-5:30pm $2 Raw Oysters & $1.5 Raw Littleneck ClamsRaw Bar
-
Freshly Shucked Riptide Oysters (MA)
on crushed ice with cocktail, fresh horseradish, mignonette and lemon wedge
$3.95
-
Freshly Shucked Salutation Cove Oysters (PEI)
on crushed ice with cocktail, fresh horseradish, mignonette and lemon wedge
$3.95
-
Freshly Shucked Littleneck Clams
on crushed ice with cocktail, fresh horseradish, and lemon wedge
$2.25
available in any quantity
-
Peel n Eat Shrimp
chilled, dusted with old bay seasoning
1/4# $11
1/2# $17
Speciality Drinks
-
Maxie-Rita
Arette blanco tequila, cointreau, triple sec, sour & real lime juice.
$12
-
State Street Hurricane
Dark & light rum, passion fruit and real lime juice.
$12
-
Cajun Bloody Mary
Vodka, tomato juice, horseradish & cajun seasoning, garnished with shrimp.
$11
-
Oyster Shooter
Vodka, fresh-shucked oyster & cajun bloody juice.
$7.50
-
Mojito!
Light rum with muddled limes, fresh mint, sugar and soda.
$11
-
Sazerac Sazerac
Pernod coated glass with sazerac rye, peychaud’s bitters, simple syrup, served ‘up’.
$12.50
-
Tipsy Gardener
Hangar one vodka, st. germain, fresh lemons & soda.
$11
-
Skyy Citrus Cosmopolitan
Skyy citrus vodka, cointreau, fresh limes & cranberry, served ‘up’.
$12
-
Supper Club Sidecar
Maker’s mark bourbon, cointreau & lemonade with a sugared rim, served ‘up’.
$12
-
Maxie Mule
Vodka, whiskey, bourbon, rum or tequila, squeeze of limes, ithaca ginger beer, on the rocks.
mkt
-
Maxie’s Pimm’s Cup
Muddled cucumber with pimm’s, sour and ginger.
$10
-
Hendrick's Experience
hendrick's gin, st. germain, muddled cucumber, soda
$11
-
Finger Lakes Old Fashioned
McKenzie bourbon, peychaud's bitters, brown sugar, orange, on the rocks
$12.50
-
Caipirinha
cachaça, lime, sugar
$10
Wine by the Glass
Sparkling
-
Blanc de Blancs, Veuve Ambal, NV
(Jura, FR) apricot, almond, refreshing.
$9
Rose
-
Rosé of Pinot Noir, The Pinot Project, 2024
(Vias, FR) raspberry, rose petals, bright acidity
$10
White
-
Sauvignon Blanc, Thresher, 2025
(Central Valley, Chile) citrus, bell pepper, fresh.
$8.50
-
Chardonnay Reserve, Atwater Vineyards, 2022
(Burdett, NY) crisp, toasty, balanced
$12
Red
-
Malbec, Vive, 2024
(Mendoza, ARG) blackberries, cocoa, round tannins
$10
-
Cabernet Sauvignon, Crosby, 2022
(California) red currant & black plum, soft tannins, dry.
$9
Draft Beer
-
NY Seneca Lodge Amber Ale
5.3% ABV
9 oz. $5.50
16 oz. $7.50
23 oz. $10
-
NY Southern Tier 8 Days a Week Blonde Ale
4.8% ABV
9 oz. $5
16 oz. $7
23 oz. $9.50
-
NY Lucky Hare Falcon Punch IPA
6.2% ABV
9 oz. $6
16 oz. $8
23 oz. $11
-
NY Sloop NY Pale Ale
5.2% ABV
9 oz. $6
16 oz. $8
23 oz. $11
Bottles & Cans
-
NY Utica Club
(can) 5.2% ABV
$5
-
Pabst Blue Ribbon
(16oz can) 4.6% ABV
$5
-
Labatt Blue
5% ABV
$5.50
-
Miller Lite
4.2% ABV
$5.50
-
Michelob Ultra
4.2% ABV
$6
-
Stella Artois Liberte N/A
0.0% ABV
$7.50
-
Abita Turbodog
5.6% ABV
$6.50
-
Hoegaarden
4.9% ABV
$7.50
-
NY Ithaca Flower Power
(can) 7.2% ABV
$8.50
-
Founders All Day IPA
(can) 4.7% ABV
$6.50
-
Guinness Draught
(can) 4.2% ABV
$8
-
NY Finger Lakes Cider House "This Cider Plants Trees"
(can) 8.4% ABV
$9
-
Athletic Run Wild IPA N/A
(can) <0.5%ABV
$6.50
-
Stone Buenaveza Lager
(can) 4.7%ABV
$8
-
Ghostfish Grapefruit IPA
(Gluten Free) 5.5% ABV
$8.50
Non-Alcoholic Beverages
-
Cola, Diet Cola, Lemon-Up, Ginger Ale
$4.50
-
Black Currant Iced Tea
$4.50
-
Ithaca Soda Co. Root Beer
$5
-
Ithaca Soda Co. Ginger Beer
$5
-
Big Wiggle
(lemon-up w/a cranberry float)
$5
-
Saratoga Sparkling Water
(28 oz)
$7
-
Lime Rickey
(real lime juice, simple syrup and soda)
$5.50
-
Shirley Temple or Roy Rogers
$4.50
-
Tropical Storm
(passionfruit, lime juice, grenadine)
$7
-
Juice
cranberry, oj, grapefruit, pineapple, or tomato
$5
-
Hot Cocoa
(with whipped cream)
$5
-
Black, Green, & Herbal Hot Teas
$4.50
-
Equal Exchange Fair Trade Organic Coffee/Decaf
$4.50
Desserts
-
Key Lime Pie
graham cracker crust, raspberry sauce, whipped cream
$11
-
Maxie’s Chocolate Marquise Cake
chocolate devil’s food cake, chocolate marquise, chocolate glaze, raspberry sauce, freshly whipped cream.
$13
-
Banana Chocolate Coconut Cream Pie
bananas, pastry cream, toasted coconut chocolate sauce, freshly whipped cream
$13
-
Purity Ice Cream
with freshly whipped cream
Scoop $4
Dish (2 scoops) $7
Don't forget to ask about tonight's sweet plate special